VERSION-BOUND SOURCE CLAIMS
Compare exact dataset counts, source-authored aggregates, counting universes, the open Soviet/Vela conflict, and currentness questions without converting the docket into a historical verdict.
HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
The exact supplied CSV contains 2,058 event-level rows; this is a source-bounded count, not 2,058 independently verified devices or tests.
DATASET_COUNT_REPRODUCED_FROM_EXACT_SOURCE · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 1 source origin(s)HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
The exact supplied CSV contains 715 Soviet Union rows.
DATASET_COUNT_REPRODUCED_FROM_EXACT_SOURCE · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 1 source origin(s)HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
The companion report states 714 Soviet rows; the exact supplied CSV contains 715.
SOURCE_CLAIM_UNVERIFIED · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 1 source origin(s)HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
The companion report says a disputed Vela row was added; the exact supplied CSV contains no 1979-09-22 row.
OPEN_SOURCE_INTERNAL_CONFLICT · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 2 source origin(s)HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
The supplied history report states 2,121 official tests and approximately 2,476 devices under its own counting conventions.
SOURCE_CLAIM_UNVERIFIED · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 1 source origin(s)HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
The supplied sources use different Soviet totals and counting units: 727 tests / 981 devices in the history report, 715 exact CSV event rows, and 714 stated companion-report rows.
SOURCE_CLAIM_UNVERIFIED · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 3 source origin(s)HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
The supplied history report and exact CSV both show 1,032 U.S. test/event rows, while the report separately states 1,132 devices.
PARTIAL_NUMERIC_ALIGNMENT_SCOPE_UNRESOLVED · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 2 source origin(s)HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
The supplied dataset treats Hiroshima and Nagasaki as wartime detonations, separate from nuclear tests.
SOURCE_SCOPE_DECLARED_REVIEW_PENDING · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 2 source origin(s)HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
Within the exact supplied CSV, 1962 has 178 event rows and is the file’s peak year.
DATASET_COUNT_REPRODUCED_FROM_EXACT_SOURCE · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 1 source origin(s)HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
The supplied methodology uses one event row for grouped same-day detonations and keeps device counts separate.
SOURCE_METHOD_CLAIM_UNVERIFIED · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 1 source origin(s)CURRENT PRIMARY-SOURCE STATUS — REVIEWED THROUGH 2026-07-25
Current CTBTO material describes the completed IMS design as 321 monitoring stations plus 16 laboratories (337 facilities) and reported 307 certified facilities operating on 6 February 2026. Design capacity, certification, operation, availability, and detection limits remain distinct.
CURRENT_PRIMARY_SOURCE_CONFIRMED_SCOPE_LIMITED · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 2 source origin(s)CURRENT PRIMARY-SOURCE STATUS — REVIEWED THROUGH 2026-07-25
CTBTO stated on 14 January 2026 that the last confirmed nuclear test occurred on 3 September 2017 at Punggye-ri and that no later nuclear test explosion had been declared or detected by its network through that source date. This negative-evidence statement is date- and capability-bound.
CURRENT_PRIMARY_SOURCE_CONFIRMED_THROUGH_SOURCE_DATE · OPEN_UNASSIGNED · 2 source origin(s)HISTORICAL DATASET CLAIM — SOURCE REVIEW REQUIRED
NCR-008 · SCOPE DEFINITION
The supplied dataset treats Hiroshima and Nagasaki as wartime detonations, separate from nuclear tests.
1c69f4fd747ec071bdd81bf5a8e85bce0defe12434312bc36218282f4367f72fThe companion report says Hiroshima and Nagasaki were retained because the request covered tests and detonations, while some official test volumes exclude them because they were not tests.
CLASSIFY
Use contains, states, estimates, models, projects, proposes, alleges, or finds according to the actual source and adjudication state.
Open the workbenchCORRECT
Bind corrections to stable claim IDs, prior wording, reason, evidence, downstream routes, and reopening conditions.
Read the correction guideREVIEW
Readiness is not assignment. Reviewer identity, scope, independence, evidence access, rationale, and disposition remain empty until actually supplied.
Review packet readiness